23 Perfect Valentine's Day Gifts for New Boyfriends to Impress and Delight

Valentine’s Day is the perfect opportunity to celebrate your new relationship and show him how much you care. Finding the right Valentine's Day gifts can feel overwhelming, especially if this is your first Valentine’s Day together or you’ve just started dating. The key is choosing a V-Day gift that feels thoughtful and fits the stage of your relationship, something he’ll love without going overboard. 

Whether you’re looking for a simple gift, a playful keepsake, or something special for a date night, these Valentine's gifts are perfect for impressing and delighting your new boyfriend. Spend time creating memories with a Valentine’s Day present that captures the fun and excitement of the holidays while showing him you’re genuinely interested in building a connection.

1. Sentimental Gift Box Set

Price: On sale for $34.99

This Sentimental Gift Box Set is one of the most romantic Valentine’s Day gifts that'll make your boyfriend feel truly special. The personalized keepsake box can be customized with his name, initials, or even a heartfelt message on the inside, making it a unique and meaningful present. 

Choose from a selection of add-ons like a wallet, lighter, blade, and tactical pen, all of which can also be personalized for a unique touch he’ll love. Perfect for celebrating your new relationship, this gift is crafted to hold lasting memories.

Related: Gift Sets for Men Thoughtful and Practical Presents for Every Occasion!

2. Photo and Hearts Boxers

Price: $29.99

Make him laugh and feel loved with these playful Photo and Hearts Boxers, one of the cutest Valentine’s gifts for guys. 

Choose his size and favorite color, including black, white, grey, or navy, and personalize it with a photo surrounded by heart designs. Made from 95% cotton and 5% spandex, they’re as comfortable as they are fun. These boxers are a unique way to add a romantic touch to your relationship while giving him a practical present he’ll love.

Related: Cute and Funny Valentine's Day Gifts to Bring Laughter and Love!

3. Personalized Keepsake Wood Watch

Price: On sale for $39.99

Celebrate your relationship with the Personalized Keepsake Wood Watch, a timeless Valentine’s Day gift he’ll love. This elegant watch is made from premium Sandalwood and genuine leather for a sophisticated look. 

Add custom engraving, such as a meaningful date or message, to make it uniquely his. A romantic and stylish choice, this present combines practicality with sentimental value, perfect for your boyfriend.

Related: Personalized Watches Timeless Gifts for Every Special Moment!

4. Personalized Sexy Gift Set

Price: $59.99

Add excitement to your Valentine’s Day celebration with this Personalized Sexy Gift Set, a romantic present that'll bring a playful touch to your relationship. 

The custom gift box, available in cherry, burl, or black, doubles as a cigar humidor and includes sleek black cuffs, personalized boxers, and a pine-scented soy candle. Perfect for Valentine’s gifts for guys who appreciate a mix of flirty and functional, this set shows how much you care.

Related: Sexiest Valentine's Day Gifts to Ignite Passion and Romance!

5. Magic Heart Light Bulb

Price: $40.00

Light up his world with the Rechargeable Cordless Magic Heart Light Bulb, one of the most unique Valentine’s presents for your boyfriend. 

This perfect gift is made from durable materials, it features hundreds of tiny LEDs that create a glowing pink heart filament. Compact and stylish, this romantic keepsake is perfect for creating a cozy ambiance in any space, making it a Valentine’s Day gift he’ll love.

6. Personalized Puzzle Set

Price: $39.99

Celebrate your relationship in a creative way with this Personalized Puzzle Set, a romantic Valentine’s gift that'll make your boyfriend smile. Customize the wooden box with your names and the heart-shaped puzzle with up to eight heartfelt messages. 

Made from high-quality walnut-finished plywood, this present adds a personal and fun touch to your Valentine’s celebration. It’s perfect for showing him how much he means to you.

7. Couples Photo Keychain

Price: $12.99

Keep your favorite memory close with this Couples Photo Keychain, a perfect Valentine’s gift for guys who love thoughtful presents. 

This perfect gift is made from high-quality 1/8" acrylic, it’s durable and stylish, measuring 2" x 2.75". Add a special photo, names, or a meaningful message to personalize it for your boyfriend. This romantic and practical keepsake ensures he’ll love carrying a reminder of your relationship wherever he goes.

Related: Cheap Valentine's Day Gifts for Him Thoughtful and Affordable Ideas!

8. Custom Couple Bobblehead

Price: $11.07 - $237.38

Give your boyfriend a Valentine’s Day gift that’s as fun as it is meaningful with this Personalized Custom Couple Bobblehead. Made from polymer clay, this custom bobblehead can be personalized with photos to reflect your unique features. 

It’s a playful and creative way to celebrate your relationship while giving him a gift that he’ll love displaying. Perfect for Valentine’s gifts that are both romantic and lighthearted, this bobblehead is a memorable keepsake for your special guy.

9. Personalized Leather Wallet

Price: $49.99

A personalized leather wallet is one of the most thoughtful Valentine’s Day gifts that'll impress your boyfriend. 

Crafted from high-quality genuine leather, it offers durability with a soft, luxurious feel. Personalize the wallet with his initials on the front and a heartfelt message on the inside, creating a unique and meaningful keepsake. The compact design fits comfortably in his pocket while offering ample space for cash, cards, and IDs. This gift is a perfect way to show how much you care this Valentine’s Day.

Related: Stylish Personalized Wallets for Men Thoughtful and Unique Gifts!

10. Love You Forever Frame

Price: $19.99

Celebrate your relationship with the Love You Forever Picture Frame, one of the most romantic Valentine’s Day gifts for your boyfriend. 

This picture frame is designed to hold a 5x7 favorite photo of you and your man, this frame is the perfect keepsake for your special memories. The elegant design features the touching text "Love You Forever," making it a meaningful gift he'll cherish. It’s a simple yet heartfelt way to express your love this Valentine’s Day.

Related: Custom Personalized Picture Frames Thoughtful Gifts for Every Occasion!

11. Love Is Art Kit

Price: $60.00

For a Valentine’s Day gift that'll spark creativity and romance, the Love Is Art Kit is a standout choice. Body paint, a blank canvas, and the connection between two lovers combine to create a one-of-a-kind masterpiece. 

Perfect for couples looking to spend quality time together, this interactive gift celebrates your bond while giving you a unique keepsake to commemorate your relationship. It’s a playful and intimate way to express your love.

12. Kinky Gift Box Set

Price: $89.99

Turn up the heat with this Kinky Gift Box Set, a Valentine’s Day gift that’ll add excitement to your relationship. 

The set includes two custom whiskey glasses, a pine-scented candle, and engraved handcuffs with keys, all presented in a sleek gift box. Personalize the items for a thoughtful touch that he’ll love. Perfect for a playful Valentine’s night, this gift brings romance and fun into your celebration.

13. Custom Message Shortbread Cookies

Price: $40.00

Satisfy his sweet tooth with these Custom Message Shortbread Cookies, a creative Valentine’s Day gift he'll enjoy. Each box includes 24 cookies made from high-quality ingredients like flour, butter, and vanilla extract. 

Personalize the cookies with three lines of text (up to 12 characters per line) for a unique and tasty way to share your love. These sweet treats are perfect for adding a personal and delicious touch to your Valentine’s celebration.

14. Sentimental Custom Decanter

Price: On sale for $49.99

The Sentimental Custom Decanter is a sophisticated Valentine’s Day gift that combines elegance and sentiment. 

Crafted from premium glass, it features a generous 25.36-ounce capacity, perfect for whiskey, bourbon, or scotch. Personalize the decanter with his name, initials, or a heartfelt message to make it uniquely his. This gift is a stylish way to show him how much he means to you, and it’s something he’ll treasure for years to come.

Related: Elegant Personalized Whiskey Decanters Perfect Gifts for Enthusiasts!

15. Ferrero Rocher Collection Hazelnut Chocolates

Price: $11.97

You can’t go wrong with the Ferrero Rocher Collection, a classic Valentine’s Day gift that’ll make your boyfriend smile. 

This luxurious assortment includes three decadent varieties: Rocher, Raffaello, and Rondnoir. Made from high-quality ingredients like milk chocolate, hazelnuts, and cocoa butter, these indulgent treats are perfect for sharing or enjoying during a romantic evening together. It’s a sweet way to show your love.

16. Personalized Wallet Insert Card

Price: $17.99

Give your boyfriend a token of your love with a Personalized Wallet Insert Card, a small but meaningful Valentine’s Day gift he'll always keep close. Made from anodized aluminum, it’s durable and fits perfectly in his wallet. 

Choose a font and personalize it with a heartfelt message or special date, creating a sentimental keepsake that’ll remind him of you every day. This gift is a perfect blend of practicality and romance.

17. Scratch-Off Date Night Cards

Price: $16.99

Keep the spark alive with the "It's a Date!" scratch-off poster, a good gift for your first Valentine’s Day together. Now featuring a new and improved design, the cards come in a larger, more giftable box, with each card measuring 5" x 4". 

This game includes 40 romantic and adventurous scratch-off date ideas, perfect for making every date night unique and exciting. Whether it’s your first date or a fun outing to celebrate an occasion like his birthday, this interactive poster adds a personal touch to your time together. Luckily, this thoughtful gift will turn any bad time into a memorable adventure you’ll both be glad to share.

18. Personalized Built-In Love Photo Ornament

Price: $29.99

Celebrate your cherished moments with the Personalized Built-In Love Photo Ornament, a perfect present for your husband or boyfriend. Customize the ornament with your chosen photo and text, adding a personal touch that’ll make it truly special. 

Made of functional bricks, it’s a fun way to showcase your love in versatile shapes like square, circle, or rectangle. Whether it’s your first Valentine’s Day or a meaningful treat for another occasion, this durable and creative ornament will literally make him smile every time he sees it.

19. Personalized Men's Wooden Keepsake Box

Price: On sale for $39.99

Give him a personalized keepsake box that’s both elegant and functional—a good gift for guys who appreciate thoughtful details. 

Made from high-quality Spanish Cedar wood, this box measures 9" x 8.5" x 2.25", making it perfect for storing watches, cufflinks, or mementos from your first date. Personalize it with his name or initials on top and add a heartfelt message inside for a personal touch he’ll treasure. Whether for Valentine’s Day, a birthday, or another special occasion, this keepsake box is a gift he’ll be glad to have.

20. Custom Watercolor Couple Portrait

Price: $13.31

Turn your love story into a work of art with a Custom Watercolor Couple Portrait, a perfect present for a girl or guy on your first Valentine’s Day together. Choose your style and size, personalize it with your favorite photo, and let this masterpiece add a touch of beauty to your relationship. 

Crafted from premium materials like 260gm paper, this unique gift is ideal for celebrating your first date, an anniversary, or any occasion that matters. It’s a thoughtful treat that he’ll literally love to display and cherish forever.

21. Personalized Bullet Whiskey Glass

Price: On sale for $34.99

For a special guy who enjoys fine spirits, the Personalized Bullet Whiskey Glass is a unique Valentine’s Day present he’ll love. Featuring a faux .50 caliber bullet embedded in the side, this glass makes a bold statement.

Personalize it with his name to show him how much he matters to you. With a perfect 10-ounce capacity, it’s ideal for serving whiskey neat or on the rocks, whether celebrating holidays or enjoying a quiet night with friends. Crafted from durable glass, this standout piece is both functional and memorable.

Related: Unique Personalized Whiskey Glasses Ideal Gifts for Whiskey Lovers!

22. Cupid Capper

Price: On sale for $39.99

Upgrade his style with the Cupid Capper, a sleek minimalist wallet and bottle opener that’s as functional as it is thoughtful.

This Valentine’s gift offers RFID-blocking protection, keeping his cards secure while fitting up to 12 cards in its compact design. Personalize it to make it unique for your husband, boyfriend, or special guy. Made from 100% carbon fiber and aluminum, it’s lightweight yet durable, perfect for any occasion. A practical and stylish gift that shows you’re thinking about what really matters.

23. Funny Hoodie

Price: $17.75

Add a touch of humor to his wardrobe with the Funny Girlfriend Hoodie, a playful Valentine’s gift that’ll keep him cozy and smiling. Choose the style, size, and color to make it personal, and customize it with a design or message he’ll love.

Made from a soft cotton and polyester blend, it’s perfect for casual days with friends or relaxing at home. This hoodie is a reminder of the fun and laughter you bring into his world and is a thoughtful way to celebrate your relationship.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q1: What to get a guy for Valentine's Day in a new relationship?

Choose a gift that’s thoughtful but not too overwhelming. Options include a small personalized keepsake, his favorite snacks, a stylish accessory, or a casual experience like a coffee date or movie night.

Q2: How to handle Valentine's Day in a new relationship?

Keep it light and thoughtful. Focus on spending quality time together rather than grand gestures. A small, meaningful gift or a simple date night can make the day special without adding pressure.

Q3: Do I get my boyfriend a gift for Valentine's Day?

Yes, a thoughtful gift can show you care. Keep it simple and consider his interests or something meaningful to your relationship, such as a book, a fun game, or a shared experience.

Q4: What to get for the first Valentine's Day?

For the first Valentine’s Day, choose something personal yet understated. A handwritten note, a small gift related to an inside joke, or a shared activity like a dinner date can make it memorable.

Related: 

Valentine’s Day Gifts for Boyfriend Thoughtful Ideas to Show Your Love!

Personalized Valentine's Day Gifts for Him Thoughtful Ways to Show Your Love!

Thoughtful Gifts for Boyfriend Meaningful Ideas to Show Your Love!