23 Perfect Valentine's Day Gifts for New Couples to Celebrate Their First Love

Valentine's Day is the perfect time for new couples to celebrate their budding relationship and create lasting memories. Whether it’s your first Valentine’s Day together or you’re still exploring each other’s interests, thoughtful Valentine’s gifts can make the day extra special. From personalized keepsakes to unique experiences, these Valentine's Day gifts are designed to express your feelings and strengthen the bond with your partner. 

This guide features 23 perfect Valentine’s gifts that are meaningful, affordable, and ideal for couples embarking on their love journey. Let these ideas inspire you to celebrate your relationship and make your first Valentine's Day truly unforgettable!

1. Puzzle Keepsake

Price: $59.99

Celebrate your relationship with the Anniversary Puzzle Keepsake, a perfect way to mark your first Valentine’s Day together. 

This thoughtful Valentine’s Day gift includes a puzzle measuring 8.25" x 11.5" when assembled, featuring 100 durable cardboard pieces with a UV-printed photo that’s as unique as your bond. Shipped unassembled in a natural wood windowed gift box, it can be personalized with your initials and a special date. Whether you’re celebrating the night sky of your first date or a cherished memory, this keepsake makes a truly meaningful gift for your girlfriend or partner.

2. Personalized Couples Song Photo Frame

Price: On sale for $39.99

Immortalize your favorite song with the Personalized Couples Song Photo Frame, a thoughtful Valentine’s gift for your new relationship. 

The embedded light softly illuminates your chosen lyrics, creating a warm ambiance perfect for your first Valentine’s Day. Personalize it with your names, a significant date, and your favorite song for a keepsake that tells your love story. This elegant frame is the ultimate Valentine’s Day gift for couples looking to celebrate their unique bond in style.

3. Personalized Charcuterie Board

Price: On sale for $99.99

Add a touch of luxury to your first Valentine’s Day with the Personalized Charcuterie Board. This beautiful board, made from marble and acacia wood, is perfect for sharing intimate moments over wine and treats. 

With dimensions of 16.25" x 12.00" and space for custom text, it’s a thoughtful gift that enhances any romantic occasion. Packaged in a white gift box and including utensils, bowls, and spoons, it’s ideal for couples in a new relationship who want to enjoy special Valentine’s evenings together.

4. Custom Song Plaque

Price: $39.99

Capture the soundtrack of your relationship with the Custom Song Plaque, a unique and thoughtful Valentine’s gift for your girlfriend or partner. 

Made from high-quality acrylic, this plaque displays your favorite song lyrics along with your names and a significant date. Whether it’s a romantic melody or a tune that reminds you of a night sky moment, this personalized piece adds a sentimental touch to your Valentine’s Day celebration. Display it on a desk, shelf, or bedside table to cherish the music of your love story.

5. Personalized Infinity Sign

Price: $39.99

Symbolize your infinite love with the Personalized Infinity Sign, the perfect Valentine’s Day gift for celebrating your first Valentine’s Day together. 

This timeless piece is crafted from durable metal and can be customized with two names and a special anniversary date. Available in multiple sizes and color options, it’s a thoughtful addition to any home decor. Perfect for couples in a new relationship, this gift is a beautiful way to express your everlasting bond.a

Related: Add a Personal Touch with Custom Signs for Your Home Décor!

6. Mr & Mrs Wine and Whiskey Gift Set

Price: $74.99

Celebrate your new relationship with the Mr & Mrs Wine and Whiskey Gift Set, one of the most romantic Valentine’s Day gifts for couples who just started dating or recently tied the knot. This thoughtful set features one whiskey glass and one stemless wine glass engraved with "Mr & Mrs," "Mr & Mr," or "Mrs & Mrs," along with your wedding date. 

The glasses, perfect for a cozy night in with your special someone, are dishwasher safe and hold 10 and 17 ounces respectively. Packaged in a custom birchwood box, this valentine gift is filled with love and makes a perfect keepsake for this special holiday.

Related: Personalized Whiskey Glasses: A Perfect Blend of Style and Function for Every Sip!

7. ArtPix 3D Crystal Photo

Price: $79.99

Capture the magic of your new relationship with the ArtPix 3D Crystal Photo, a unique Valentine’s Day gift for your partner. 

This heart-shaped crystal, beautifully designed to feature a three-dimensional engraving of your favorite photo, is a stunning way to commemorate your journey together. Perfect for a night of reminiscing, it comes mounted on a wood-grain frame, adding a romantic touch to any room. Whether you’ve just started dating or are celebrating your first Valentine’s Day together, this thoughtful gift is sure to fill their heart with joy.

8. Wine Gift Set

Price: $79.99

Indulge in a romantic Valentine’s Day with the Anniversary Wine Gift Set, a thoughtful and fun gift for your partner. This set features two 19 oz engraved stem wine glasses, a heart-shaped chrome bottle stopper, wooden wine charms, slate coasters, and a fresh linen-scented candle for a cozy night. 

Packaged in an elegant white box filled with pink crinkle paper and personalized with a sentimental message, this gift is perfect for couples in a new relationship or those celebrating their love. A perfect valentine gift for making the holiday extra special with your special someone.

Related: Top Gift Sets for Men: Perfect Options for Every Occasion!

9. Meaningful Photo Print on Wood

Price: $44.99

Turn your memories into art with the Meaningful Photo Print on Wood, a sentimental Valentine’s Day gift for your special someone. 

This personalized piece features high-quality photo printing on durable wood, showcasing the rustic charm of natural grain. Whether you’re celebrating a new relationship or a long-term bond, this gift is perfect for filling your space with love and warmth. Equipped with hardware for easy wall mounting, it’s ideal for a romantic holiday display or as a heartfelt reminder of your connection.

Related: Personalized Picture Frames: Cherish Your Memories with a Unique Touch!

10. Personalized Built-In Love Photo Ornament

Price: $29.99

Commemorate your first Valentine's Day with the Personalized Built-In Love Photo Ornament, a great gift for your partner. 

This keepsake allows you to customize the ornament with a cherished photo and text, creating a meaningful reminder of your relationship. Its interactive design, made of functional bricks, offers a fun way to add a playful touch to your décor. Available in square, circle, and rectangle shapes, it’s crafted from high-quality materials for durability, making it one of the most unique Valentine’s Day gifts.

11. Nuts Gift Basket Assortment

Price: $29.95

Treat your partner to the Nuts Gift Basket Assortment, a great idea for Valentine's Day gifts filled with premium flavors. 

This curated basket by Nut Haven is perfect for sharing during a cozy movie night or as a snack for a date night. Weighing 1 pound and beautifully packaged, it’s a thoughtful and fun way to show your love and celebrate the holiday with a delicious treat.

12. Personalized Wine Decanter Set

Price: $129.99

Enhance your romantic dinner or date night with the Personalized Wine Decanter Set, a great gift for your partner. 

This elegant set includes a lead-free 16 oz decanter and two 8 oz glasses, custom laser-engraved with your initials or a meaningful date. Perfect for Valentine’s Day gifts, it adds a personal touch to your celebrations and makes every sip feel special, whether it’s during a romantic dinner or an intimate movie night.

Related: Personalized Whiskey Decanters: Elegant and Timeless Gifts for Whiskey Lovers!

13. Couples Photo Keychain

Price: $12.99

Celebrate your bond with the Couples Photo Keychain, a great idea for Valentine's Day gifts that is both thoughtful and practical. 

This custom keychain showcases your favorite photo printed on durable acrylic, making it a fun way to carry a piece of your relationship wherever you go. Add a personal touch with names or a special message, and gift it to your partner to commemorate a meaningful moment or date night.

14. Personalized Blanket

Price: $29.99

Make your movie nights extra special with the Personalized Blanket, a cozy and romantic Valentine’s Day gift for your partner. 

Made from 280 GSM polyester coral fleece, it’s perfect for snuggling during a date night or adding warmth to a romantic dinner at home. Available in two rich colors and packaged in a PVC zippered pouch, it can be customized with your last name and wedding date. This great gift combines comfort and sentiment, making it a fun way to celebrate your love.

15. Custom Couple Bobbleheads

Price: $7.99 - $198.09

Capture the fun and excitement of your relationship with Custom Couple Bobbleheads, a sweet and creative Valentine’s Day gift. 

Crafted from high-quality clay, these personalized figurines are tailored to your likeness, making them a unique surprise for your partner. Choose the size and upload a photo to design a gift that brings your love story to life. Perfect for displaying at home or the office, it’s a thoughtful way to celebrate your bond.

16. Personalized Decision Maker Coin

Price: On sale for $19.99

Make decisions more exciting with the Personalized Decision Maker Coin, a creative and sweet Valentine’s Day gift for your partner. 

Crafted from premium brass, this luxurious coin can be personalized with names on each side, adding a touch of thoughtfulness. The clear labels, "Decision Coin" and "Flip to Decide," make it a fun surprise for spontaneous plans or everyday choices. Compact and portable, it’s perfect for keeping life adventurous and romantic.

17. Watercolor Couple Portrait

Price: $12.95 - $114.80

Turn your favorite photo into a creative masterpiece with the Watercolor Couple Portrait. This sweet and artistic Valentine’s Day gift allows you to bring a cherished memory to life. 

Choose the size and style, and personalize it with names or a special message to make it uniquely yours. Available as prints, frames, or canvases, this thoughtful surprise adds an exciting and romantic touch to your home decor.

18. "Wood You Be Mine" Cutting Board

Price: $59.99

Celebrate the sweet moments of your life together with the "Wood You Be Mine" Cutting Board. This creative Valentine’s Day gift is perfect for romantic dinners and date nights. 

Personalized with names and a special date, the 3/4" thick handmade board brings a unique touch to your kitchen. Its natural variations make each board one of a kind, adding an exciting and thoughtful element to your shared cooking adventures.

Related: Personalized Cutting Boards: Practical and Stylish Gifts for Any Kitchen!

19. Ferrero Rocher Confections Collection

Price: $23.70

Indulge in the sweetness of life with the Ferrero Rocher Confections Collection, a delightful Valentine’s Day surprise for your partner. 

This exciting assortment features a mix of chocolates, including Rocher, Raffaello, and Rondnoir, made with premium ingredients like hazelnuts, almonds, and coconut.

20. Coffee Travel Mug

Price: $24.99

Celebrate your journey together with the Anniversary Coffee Travel Mug, the perfect gift for your partner or friends. 

This 15 oz stainless steel mug, standing 4 7/8” high with a 3 3/8” wide base, is designed to keep beverages warm or cold during your adventures. Choose a color, add initials, and include a year to make it a memorable keepsake. The lasered silver design adds elegance, making it the best gift for a forever reminder of your love. Handwashing is recommended to maintain its lasting quality, making it a functional and heartfelt surprise for that special person.

21. Personalized Wallet Insert Card

Price: $17.99

Express your love with the Personalized Wallet Insert Card, the best gift for someone who holds a special place in your life. 

This credit card-sized insert, measuring 3 5/8" x 2 1/8", is crafted from durable anodized aluminum, making it a perfect gift that’s both practical and sentimental. Personalize it with a meaningful message, date, or names and choose a font to make it uniquely yours. Whether for your partner or a close friend, this card serves as a forever keepsake they’ll cherish. Finally, here’s a gift that ensures your person always carries a piece of your love with them, making it a truly memorable choice.

22. Personalized Photo Car Air Freshener

Price: $19.99

Freshen up your partner’s car with the Personalized Photo Car Air Freshener, a fun and memorable Valentine’s Day gift. 

Crafted from high-quality clear acrylic, this air freshener measures 2.5" x 3" with a 1/8" thickness, ensuring durability and a sleek finish. Add a high-resolution photo to achieve a clear and vibrant print that captures a cherished moment. Perfect for adding a sweet and personal touch to daily commutes, this gift is a unique way to keep memories alive.

23. Personalized Crossroads Street Sign Canvas

Price: $11.95

Celebrate your love story with the Personalized Crossroads Street Sign Canvas, a romantic and thoughtful Valentine’s gift. 

This artwork is available as a poster or framed canvas, made with high-quality materials for a vibrant and lasting design. The poster features resin-coated photo base paper with a satin finish, while the canvas, crafted from 35% cotton and 65% polyester, includes a matte satin finish and a lifelong color guarantee. Customize it with names, dates, or a meaningful message, making it a perfect addition to your home decor and a beautiful way to commemorate your journey together.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q1: What to get her for Valentine's Day in a new relationship?

In a new relationship, thoughtful yet lighthearted gifts are ideal. Consider something meaningful but not overwhelming, like a bouquet of her favorite flowers, a box of gourmet chocolates, or a cozy scarf. A handwritten note expressing your excitement about the relationship can add a personal touch.

Q2: What to gift on the first Valentine's Day?

For your first Valentine’s Day, focus on a gift that celebrates the beginning of your bond. Personalized keepsakes, such as a custom photo frame, a simple piece of jewelry, or a book you think she’d love, are great options. Experiences like a dinner date or a fun activity together can also make the day memorable.

Q3: Do you get a Valentine's gift for someone you just started dating?

Yes, but keep it simple and thoughtful to avoid putting too much pressure on a new relationship. Small gestures like a cute card, a small box of chocolates, or a coffee date can strike the perfect balance between being considerate and not overdoing it.

Q4: What is the gift for the first date of Valentine's Day?

For a Valentine’s Day first date, opt for something sweet and low-key. A single rose, a small handwritten note, or a fun experience you can share together, like ice cream or a walk in the park, can make a wonderful impression without feeling too formal.

Related: 

Make Him Feel Special with Personalized Valentine's Day Gifts for Him!

Show Your Love with Personalized Valentine's Day Gifts for Her!

Cute Valentine's Day Ideas for Couples to Make the Day Unforgettable!